I was introduced to this place during a party after the party after a sales meeting. The sales people loved it, but our group was rather large and for whatever reason we didn't end up staying. Keep reading and you'll begin to understand why.
So this afternoon, as I was driving from the beach toward Main Street just hoping to find a parking spot, I passed Chez Jay and decided Main Street could wait. An easy parking spot made this an easy decision.
My first thought when I walked in was that this was a place for regulars. I didn't know how right I was! This place turned out to be THE *dive* bar for Santa Monicans and, so I was told, various actors and other *important* people. I was passed over for a drink once and then the sweet, cute, but married (sigh) bartender asked me what I would have to drink "my love"--yes, "my love", said not once, but several times in all sorts of odd ways: how's the scampi, my love; would you like another drink, my love; here you go , my love; my love, how are you doing?; thank you very much, my love. This pervasive over-endearment was followed up by a little too much gratitude at a 20% tip, but I'm getting ahead of myself.
I messed around with the menu for awhile while sipping my Hefewiessen. A little more high-end than I expected given the atmosphere. I decided on the shrimp scampi at the recommendation of the older gentlemen to my right. It must have been my lucky day: he gave me the inside scoop on this place, mistook me for a tourist who was being mistreated, mistook me for a Londoner, grabbed me a second beer when the bartender made a mistake, and had that comfortable grand-father feeling about him. For whatever reason, he took it as his duty to make me feel comfortable and should be given many free drinks for the positive nature of this review (then again, Chez Jay does not seem to be a place that necessarily wants nice reviews). He sat eating free peanuts--yes free peanuts with shells on the floor at a place where you can order shrimp scampi and filet mignon and no burgers. Back to the scampi--wonderful shrimp though slightly overdone. So-so vegetables and what seemed to be instant rice. The clam chowder was good.
A bonus: I was given a taste of red-headed slut (a drink with Jag in it). Strangely enough, this was given to me after the bartender said "who's all in here" to himself while deciding how much extra to mix together. This was one of those events you could analzye for hours and not have a satisfactory answer. I've given up. Maybe I'll go back again and try to figure it out.
My recommendation: No one who lives near Santa Monica should die without checking this place out. But don't come here on a first date and don't come with high expectations. If you're set on eating, make a reservation. Be ready to be treated like shit if it's at all busy. Every person that came in was asked if they had a reservation (I overheard that there was only ONE reservation for the evening). Everyone was made to feel guilty that they hadn't made one. All four booths were marked reserved. You will not be seated until you're entire party arrives and the bar is a little small, so you can't be guaranteed a spot. You will not be allowed to have drinks at a table. Even one person who dropped a name was treated the same. This was my experience--well, not so much experience as what I witnessed. Maybe the lone waiter and bartender have a way of sniffing out something I'm not aware of. Maybe I passed. I was treated well myself. And, out of fairness, I should point out that their wesbite claims equal treatment for all.